Joe DeRozier
Jul 2026
My mom-in-law has been there for a few years, and the staff treats her with so much love. God bless them❤️
Story Cottage Living
1840 W Main St4.3(12 ratings)· Carmel average: 4.3
Part of Story Cottage · 3 communities · (2 others nearby)
Own this community? Update your listing · Marketing for operators
1 / 6Quick Facts
What Families Think
An automated summary of family reviews and public information. Not verified by MyLivingChoice; confirm services, staffing and pricing with the community.
Story Cottage Living is an assisted living community in Carmel, Indiana, holding a 4.3 out of 5 rating from 12 Google reviews. Beyond that rating, no detailed reviews, amenities, or pricing information were provided to give a fuller picture of the day-to-day experience.
What reviewers praise
- 4.3 out of 5 rating from Google reviewers
What reviewers flag
- No pricing information published for the community
- No amenities or specific reviewer feedback available to evaluate
AI-generated from reviews and community data.
Story Cottage Living is a senior living community in Carmel, Indiana offering Assisted Living. Amenities include Gathering / Activity Spaces, Social Activities and Housekeeping. Families rate it 4.3 out of 5 across 12 reviews.
About Story Cottage Living
Story Cottage Living is an assisted living community in Carmel, Indiana. The community offers 24-hour staff, housekeeping, medication management, and gathering spaces for social activities.
Reviewers describe the physical setting as beautiful and home-like. Several families report that staff treat residents with care and compassion. One reviewer noted that the staff "really care about the residents." However, reviews are mixed on consistency of care and attention, with one family raising concerns about staffing responsiveness during a resident's final days.
Types of Care at Story Cottage Living
Assisted Living
Amenities
Community Amenities
- 24-Hour Staff
- Gathering / Activity Spaces
- Housekeeping
- Medication Management
Activities
- Social Activities
Need help deciding?
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit. Free for families.
Help Me ChooseReviews of Story Cottage Living
4.3overall · 12 ratings combined
4.3★ on Google (12)
Sarah Johnson
Feb 2025
Beautiful place but don’t let that fool you. Most of the staff doesn’t care like they should. Residence are often unattended. My grandmother recently passed after a rough couple last days of her life. If it wasn’t for family I’m not sure my grandma would have gotten the care she deserved in her final moments with us. (Yes I am aware that there are much worse places.) Don’t get me wrong some of the staff is great, but the others are awful. ( ex: Ashlee and Ashley are both WONDERFUL. Jamaica not so much…). The people who don’t care will blame it on staffing issues, but I think it stems from something much higher than that. Let’s be real, I’ve been in multiple sectors of the healthcare field for about a decade and lets face it ….EVERYONE(including non medical facilities ) are short staffed. That doesn’t mean you stop caring or doing yoir job. These residents despite their age,health, or lack of cognitive ability are STILL PEOPLE!!! Caring for residences and their families should be your top priority or you shouldn’t be in healthcare at all. Long story short, this place is OK, but you will still absolutely have to advocate for your loved one and keep a watchful eye! Your loved one deserves better then Sotry Cottage.
Melinda Mays
Mar 2024
Story Cottage is excellent!! The staff really care about the residents and the building is SO cute...the residents really feel like they are at home!!
Carlisa Dilworth
Mar 2024
Exceptional staff and very elegant and caring environment for a loved one.
Myla Dasha
Mar 2024
This is a beautiful home with wonderful staff. It looks like a great home environment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of care does Story Cottage Living offer?
Story Cottage Living offers Assisted Living.
How much does Story Cottage Living cost?
Story Cottage Living has not published its pricing. For context, communities in Carmel that publish rates start around $3,419 per month at the median. Final costs depend on care needs and apartment selection, so contact the community for a quote.
Where is Story Cottage Living located?
Story Cottage Living is located at 1840 W Main St in Carmel, Indiana.
What do families say about Story Cottage Living?
Story Cottage Living carries a 4.3 out of 5 rating from 12 Google reviews. Reviews on MyLivingChoice come from families who confirmed a connection to the community and appear with the reviewer's first name and last initial.
How can families visit Story Cottage Living?
Submit the Request Information form on this page, or contact Story Cottage Living directly, to arrange a tour. Sharing your timeline and care needs up front helps the community prepare for your visit.
Work at Story Cottage Living? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details. It's free.
Compare with similar communities nearby
Assisted living communities within 25 miles that work with MyLivingChoice, nearest first. If you move into one we introduce you to, it pays us a referral fee, never you; we never order them by what they pay.
Not sure which is right? A real person will shortlist up to three for you, free.
Get a free shortlistNearby Communities
Other senior living options within 25 miles of Carmel.
Majestic Care of Carmel Assisted & Independent Living
Carmel, Indiana2 mi
5(3)
Assisted LivingIndependent Living
Rose Senior Living Carmel
Carmel, Indiana2.1 mi
4.9(58)
Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care
From $3,419/moIndependence Village of Carmel
Carmel, Indiana2.3 mi
4.2(66)
Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care
Willow Haven Senior Homes
Carmel, Indiana2.5 mi
5(3)
Assisted Living
Chapters Living of Carmel
Carmel, Indiana2.7 mi
4(20)
Assisted LivingIndependent LivingSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Prefer to stay home?
Home care agencies serving Carmel bring help to the house: daily living, companionship, and respite for family caregivers.
