Best Senior Living in Fishers, Indiana

12 communities found

MyLivingChoice lists 23 senior care options in Fishers: 12 communities and 11 home care agencies. Families rate them 4.4 out of 5 on average, across 899 public reviews. 2 have details confirmed by the operator.

23options listed
4.4average rating, 18 rated
899family reviews read
2operator-verified

Allisonville Meadows Assisted Living

Fishers, Indiana

4.9(119)

Assisted LivingMemory CareRespite / Short-Term Care

The Reserve at Hamilton Trace

Fishers, Indiana

5(21)

Independent Living

From $2,855/mo

Northridge Gracious Retirement Living

Fishers, Indiana

4.7(32)

Independent Living

From $3,500/mo

Independence Village of Fishers South

Fishers, Indiana

4.4(56)

Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care+1 more

Grand Brook Memory Care of Fishers

Fishers, Indiana

4.4(50)

Memory Care

From $3,442/mo

Independence Village Fishers East

Fishers, Indiana

4.4(48)

Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care

From $1,525/mo

Fishers Run Senior Apartments

Fishers, Indiana

5(1)

Independent Living

Meadow Brook Senior Living

Fishers, Indiana

4.2(53)

Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care+1 more

Legacy Living Fishers

Fishers, Indiana

Assisted LivingSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care

Allisonville Meadows

Fishers, Indiana

4.1(159)

Memory CareRespite / Short-Term CareSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care

Lake Meadows Senior Assisted Living

Fishers, Indiana

4(47)

Assisted LivingMemory Care

Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living

Fishers, Indiana

4(176)

Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care

Best-rated senior living in Fishers

Ranked by family rating, weighted by how many families have reviewed each one. No community pays to appear here.

1
Allisonville Meadows Assisted LivingVerified
4.9 (119 reviews)· Assisted Living, Memory Care, Respite / Short-Term Care
Families overwhelmingly praise Allisonville Meadows for warm, family-like care, cleanliness, and strong communication from nursing staff, especially in the assisted living and memory care neighborhoods. A small number of…
2
The Reserve at Hamilton Trace
5 (21 reviews)· Independent Living
Families describe The Reserve at Hamilton Trace as a warm, well-maintained independent living community where residents stay active and socially engaged. Reviewers consistently praise the caring, attentive staff and the…
3
Northridge Gracious Retirement Living
4.7 (32 reviews)· Independent Living
Families and visitors describe Northridge as a warm, tightly knit independent living community with an active social calendar, praising the staff and especially the activities director by name. The community holds a…
4
Independence Village of Fishers South
4.4 (56 reviews)· Assisted Living, Independent Living, Memory Care, Respite / Short-Term Care
Most reviewers describe Independence Village of Fishers South as a warm, family-like community with attentive, caring staff, clean grounds, and active social programming. However, a handful of detailed reports describe…
5
Grand Brook Memory Care of Fishers
4.4 (50 reviews)· Memory Care
Reviews for Grand Brook Memory Care of Fishers are sharply divided. Many families describe a warm, home-like community where staff know residents personally and go out of their way to help, while several other families…
6
Independence Village Fishers East
4.4 (48 reviews)· Assisted Living, Independent Living, Memory Care
Families describe Independence Village Fishers East as a friendly, well-staffed community where residents often feel like part of a family, with several reviewers praising the smooth move-in process and the dining and…
7
Meadow Brook Senior Living
4.2 (53 reviews)· Assisted Living, Independent Living, Memory Care, Respite / Short-Term Care· 94 units
Meadow Brook draws a wide range of feedback: many families praise long-tenured staff members by name and describe warm, attentive care across independent living, assisted living, and memory care, while a notable cluster…
8
Allisonville MeadowsVerified
4.1 (159 reviews)· Memory Care, Respite / Short-Term Care, Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care· 161 units
Families describe Allisonville Meadows as a clean, well-staffed skilled nursing community where residents recovering from surgery or falls received attentive rehab care. Reviewers repeatedly highlight the compassion of…
9
Lake Meadows Senior Assisted Living
4 (47 reviews)· Assisted Living, Memory Care
Lake Meadows draws a wide range of feedback: many families and residents praise the cleanliness, friendly staff, and active social calendar, while a notable number of reviewers report serious concerns about…
10
Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living
4 (176 reviews)· Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care· 108 units
Most reviewers describe Hamilton Trace as a clean, well-run community with attentive, respectful staff, particularly praising individual nurses and administrators for compassionate care and help navigating Medicaid. One…

What families say about senior living in Fishers

Counted across the review summaries of 21 Fishers communities: the share whose families mention each theme.

Praised most

Caring, attentive staff 95%
Cleanliness 48%
Building and grounds 43%
Activities and social life 38%
Food and dining 33%

Concerns raised

Communication with families 43%
Staff attitude 33%
Staffing levels and turnover 29%
Cost and billing 29%

“This assisted living building has been a godsend for our family. Memory care offers outstanding care. The building is clean and serves wonderful meals. Staff are caring and go above and beyond.”
Isabelle, on Allisonville Meadows Assisted Living, Jul 2026

“I attended the Block Party event with my grandma yesterday and I am so impressed by the cleanliness of this building. The common areas, public restrooms, the grounds... all pristine! The caregivers were very kind, helpful, and tentative to the residents. And of course the food is always good!"”
Jackson, on Independence Village of Fishers South, Jun 2026

“Loved the tour of Independence Village East with Larry. Staff were wonderful and the facility is beautiful. Lots of amenities offered to residents and the location is prime. We were looking at their assisted living services and they offer everything we would need along with some extras.”
Julie, on Independence Village Fishers East, May 2026

Senior Living in Fishers: the figures

•Among the 4 that publish a starting price, prices start at $1,525 a month with a median of $3,149.
•Most common amenities: medication management (15), 24-hour staff (15), dietary accommodations (12), emergency call system (12), gathering / activity spaces (11), housekeeping (11).

Senior Living near Fishers

Cities within about 35 miles with senior living inventory, and how families rate it.

City	Communities	RatingAverage rating	Distance
Noblesville5.9 mi	13	4.2 / 5	5.9 mi
Carmel7.2 mi	26	4.3 / 5	7.2 mi
Westfield9.7 mi	5	4.5 / 5	9.7 mi
Indianapolis13.3 mi	111	4 / 5	13.3 mi
Zionsville14.4 mi	7	4.6 / 5	14.4 mi
Greenfield15.3 mi	6	4.1 / 5	15.3 mi
Anderson20 mi	21	4.1 / 5	20 mi
Brownsburg22.3 mi	5	4.4 / 5	22.3 mi

All of Indiana: Senior Living in Indiana. Closer to home? Compare senior living near you, sorted by distance.

About these figures

Computed on October 20, 2026 from the 23 communities listed in Fishers, 899 public family reviews on Google, Yelp and MyLivingChoice, state licensing records and, for nursing homes, CMS Care Compare. The best-rated list ranks communities by average family rating weighted by how many families have reviewed each one, so a 4.9 from three reviews does not outrank a 4.7 from two hundred. No community pays to appear in the best-rated list or in these figures; sponsored and partner listings in the directory results are marked as such. Figures refresh as listings and reviews change.

Reading on this

Guides from MyLivingChoice that families in Fishers ask about.

Not in Fishers? Senior living near me finds communities around wherever you are.

Senior Living in Fishers: Common Questions

How many senior living communities are in Fishers, Indiana?

MyLivingChoice lists 23 senior living communities in Fishers, Indiana, each with photos, care details, and reviews from families.

How much does senior living cost in Fishers?

Among Fishers communities that publish pricing, senior living starts around $1,525/month, with an average published starting rate near $2,831/month. Final costs depend on care needs and apartment choice.

Which senior living communities in Fishers are rated highest?

Based on combined ratings across Google, Yelp, and MyLivingChoice reviews, top-rated options include The Reserve at Hamilton Trace (5★, 21 ratings), Guardian Care (5★, 19 ratings), FirstLight Home Care of Fishers (5★, 9 ratings).

What types of senior care are available in Fishers?

Beyond senior living, Fishers has at-home care (7 communities), memory care (7 communities), assisted living (6 communities), independent living (6 communities), home health (4 communities). Every option is listed with photos, reviews, and contact details.

How do families rate senior living in Fishers?

Families rate Fishers senior living communities 4.4 out of 5 on average, across 899 public Google reviews of local communities.

What do families praise, and complain about, in Fishers senior living communities?

Across the review summaries of 21 Fishers communities, the most common praise is caring, attentive staff (mentioned for 95%), cleanliness (mentioned for 48%), building and grounds (mentioned for 43%). The most common concerns are communication with families (43%), staff attitude (33%), staffing levels and turnover (29%).