MyLivingChoice

Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living

11851 Cumberland Rd

4(176 ratings)

Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living — photo 11 / 5

Quick Facts

Total units
108
Care continuum offered
Independent living through memory support on-site
Insurance accepted
Accepts various insurance carriers through CarDon

What Families Think

Most reviewers describe Hamilton Trace as a clean, well-run community with attentive, respectful staff, particularly praising individual nurses and administrators for compassionate care and help navigating Medicaid. One detailed review, however, raised serious concerns about overnight staffing levels and lapses in basic care and cleanliness in the rehab wing.

The Good

  • Staff frequently described as kind and professional
  • Residents treated with respect and dignity
  • Praised for helping families navigate Medicaid paperwork
  • Wound care nurse singled out for excellent skill
  • Facility described as clean and well-run overall

The Bad

  • One detailed report of only 1 nurse and 1 CNA for 42 overnight patients
  • Slow response times reported, e.g. 45 minutes for a bedpan
  • One report of dining room floor not cleaned daily
  • One report of a resident denied help eating despite needing it

AI-generated from reviews and community data.

About Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living

Hamilton Trace of Fishers is a senior living community in Fishers, Indiana, offering a full continuum of care including Independent Living, Assisted Living, Rehabilitation, Long-Term Care, and Memory Support.

The community emphasizes a personalized approach to care, providing as much or as little assistance as residents need. Staff are positioned as experienced in all areas of senior living and committed to guiding residents through their care journey.

The community features modern facilities and encourages an active lifestyle. Residents participate in daily exercise programs and can enjoy meals prepared by an on-site chef, with facilities available for residents to gather with family and guests.

Located in Fishers, a suburb of Indianapolis, Hamilton Trace is situated near shops, entertainment, recreation, places of worship, and medical offices. The community accepts various insurance carriers through CarDon.

Types of Care

Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care

Need help deciding?

Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit — free, and you choose who contacts you.

Help Me Choose

Reviews

4overall · 176 ratings combined

4★ on Google (176)

Kelli Thompson

Jul 2026

via Google

My grandmother is a resident of Hamilton Trace and has been taken care of so well! She isn’t part of a nursing home, the staff are apart of her home! Huge shout out to Brittany Walker, business office manager, for assisting and facilitating the life decision and move for my grandmother!

cynthia marie

Jul 2026

via Google

The facility was clean and the staff was exceptional. Lyndsey Urban was there to help with all of my concerns about by mothers care and I never had to question whether she was receiving the care and attention she needed!

Jake Ferrill

Jul 2026

via Google

Hamilton Trace is a 5 star facility with an outstanding staff! Lyndsey Urban is a knowledgeable nurse that is dedicated to her staff and patients.

Stephanie Matthews

Jul 2026

via Google

We moved my mother in law in here, and she has been cared for so well. I would recommend everyone to bring their loved ones here. The staff is so kind and caring, especially Lyndsay Urban.

Martin pumani

Jul 2026

via Google

I work with Lyndsey Urban and she’s great. She’s easy to get along with and always so helpful!

Request information

Ask about availability, pricing, or a tour. Your details go only to Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living — never sold or shared.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of care does Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living offer?

Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living offers Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care.

Where is Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living located?

Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living is located at 11851 Cumberland Rd in Fishers, Indiana.

What do families say about Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living?

Most reviewers describe Hamilton Trace as a clean, well-run community with attentive, respectful staff, particularly praising individual nurses and administrators for compassionate care and help navigating Medicaid. One detailed review, however, raised serious concerns about overnight staffing levels and lapses in basic care and cleanliness in the rehab wing.

Work at Hamilton Trace Family-first Senior Living? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details — it's free.

Nearby Communities

Other senior living options within 25 miles of Fishers.