8400 Vamo Road
4.1(58 ratings)· Sarasota average: 4.1
1 / 5CMS Care Compare
Reviews of Bay Village of Sarasota are sharply divided: several visitors and social-media posts praise the beautiful waterfront setting, warm activities staff, and clean, welcoming environment, while at least two reviewers raise serious concerns about clinical care quality, particularly around nursing knowledge and follow-through on medical orders. Overall Google rating sits at 4.1 from 58 reviews, reflecting this mix of glowing praise and pointed criticism.
AI-generated from reviews and community data.
Bay Village of Sarasota is a Life Plan Community in Sarasota, Florida, offering a continuum of care for older adults seeking an enriched living experience. The community is a nonprofit, accredited organization that emphasizes connection, lifelong learning, and authentic community engagement.
The community features diverse dining options, including "Port of Call Dining" for international cuisines and "Marker 48 Grill" for lighter fare and grab-and-go meals, along with vegetarian options. A modernized wellness center spans 10,488 square feet and includes a salon, spa terrace, changing rooms, a fitness studio, and separate cardio and strength training facilities to serve residents' health and wellness needs.
Bay Village offers extensive amenities and programs designed to foster connection and enrichment. The library, managed by resident volunteers, contains over 6,000 regular and large print books. A state-of-the-art theatre features surround sound, acoustic panels, and theatre-style seating. The Palm Event Center hosts special programs, activities, and events for both large gatherings and intimate occasions, while gathering spaces throughout the community provide cozy environments with updated décor, flooring, and paint.
The community emphasizes intellectual engagement and social connection through educational events, lectures, Great Courses series, and book discussions. Residents note the vibrant cultural and intellectual environment that Sarasota offers, with Bay Village positioning itself as a hub for intellectually curious individuals. A gift shop and country store provides convenience items including candy, stationery, small gifts, and cold drinks.
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit — free, and you choose who contacts you.
Help Me Choose4.1overall · 58 ratings combined
4.1★ on Google (58)
Ally M.
May 2026
“Don’t fall for the Hotel-Like” atmosphere. As soon as you need medical care; run for the hills! One million dollars btw ! 🫣 I’ve had friends who could not wait to leave! Oh, lastly, all the monies go to “curb appeal” … not the wellbeing of residents. Shameful.
JENNIFER CURRIER
Apr 2026
The director of nursing none of the other nurses are knowledgeable about supeapubic catheters! The staff was rude! My clients needs were not being met. I have never seen so many clueless nurses in my almost 30 years of being a Cna. I knew more than them. Also they did not listen to anything I told them about her medication and her regimen. Getting orders changed was impossible. I signed her out Monday she got her there on Thursday evening. Visit your loved ones advocate for them. My client had 24/7 care while she was there because we couldn’t trust the staff to do their part. Also they charted she was showered and she absolutely was not.
Agnes Agborsangaya
Mar 2026
This place is amazing. The staff and patients are great.
Carlos Smith
Nov 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A Truly Beautiful Place — Full of Heart and Compassion For anyone who can’t personally care for their loved ones anymore, I want you to know there are still places where love and compassion shine — and Bay Village of Sarasota is one of them. I had the honor of visiting today with my emotional support goat, Billy, and it was one of the most heartwarming experiences I’ve ever had. The residents were full of joy, laughter, and curiosity — most thought Billy was a dog at first and did a triple blink when they realized he was actually a goat! It was priceless. What made the day even more special was Virginia Johnson, the Activities Coordinator. She literally went door to door, gently knocking and saying, “Hey, you’ve got a visitor today — Billy the Goat!” The way she encouraged everyone to join in and made each person feel included was beautiful. You can tell she truly loves her residents and cares for them like family. The building was spotless, every room looked amazing, and every staff member I met — from the nurses to the CNAs and front desk — was welcoming, kind, and professional. If you’re ever faced with the hard decision of finding a place for your parents or loved ones, I would highly recommend Bay Village. After what I saw today, I would even be happy to be somewhere like this myself one day. It’s not just a senior community — it’s a home filled with heart, laughter, and real human connection. ❤️
Naomi Sprung
Jan 2024
Serenity and Beauty. The water is calm and mesmerising with beautiful vistas wherever you look. Gorgeous sky meeting water and huge birds swooping and diving into the water. The water looks magical and it is so peaceful and inviting. Beauty and peace.
Bay Village of Sarasota Inc offers Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care.
Bay Village of Sarasota Inc is located at 8400 Vamo Road in Sarasota, Florida.
Reviews of Bay Village of Sarasota are sharply divided: several visitors and social-media posts praise the beautiful waterfront setting, warm activities staff, and clean, welcoming environment, while at least two reviewers raise serious concerns about clinical care quality, particularly around nursing knowledge and follow-through on medical orders. Overall Google rating sits at 4.1 from 58 reviews, reflecting this mix of glowing praise and pointed criticism.
Work at Bay Village of Sarasota Inc? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details — it's free.
Other senior living options within 25 miles of Sarasota.
Sarasota, Florida
4.5(492)
Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Sarasota, Florida
4(225)
Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Sarasota, Florida
4.1(193)
Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Sarasota, Florida
4.6(137)
Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Sarasota, Florida
3.3(122)
Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Sarasota, Florida
4.2(89)
Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care