Best Senior Living in New Albany, Indiana
17 communities found
New Albany offers 31 senior living options in total, made up of 17 residential communities and 14 home care or similar agencies. Among the 26 communities with ratings, the average score is 4.2 out of 5, drawn from more than 1,054 reviews. Six communities report Medicare star ratings, averaging 3.2, with one earning five stars and one earning only one.
- 31options listed
- 4.2average rating, 26 rated
- 1,054family reviews read
- 0small homes, 10 or fewer
Autumn Woods Health Campus
New Albany, Indiana
4.8(182)
Memory CareSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care
The Mansion on Main
New Albany, Indiana
4.8(49)
Assisted Living
Renewity Residential Care Home
New Albany, Indiana
5(13)
Assisted Living
Rivercrest Senior Living
New Albany, Indiana
4.9(14)
Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care
St. Croix Hospice
New Albany, Indiana
5(4)
Home health
Historic Silvercrest Patio Homes
New Albany, Indiana
4.5(18)
Independent Living
Green Valley Care Center
New Albany, Indiana
4.4(115)
Memory CareSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Bennett Place
New Albany, Indiana
4.4(43)
Assisted LivingRespite / Short-Term Care
Muir Manor
New Albany, Indiana
4.5(11)
Independent Living
Lincoln Hills
New Albany, Indiana
4.3(166)
Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care
The Villages at Historic Silvercrest
New Albany, Indiana
4.2(62)
Assisted LivingIndependent LivingRespite / Short-Term Care+1 more
Rivercrest Patio Homes
New Albany, Indiana
4(1)
Independent Living
Best-rated senior living in New Albany
Ranked by family rating, weighted by how many families have reviewed each one. No community pays to appear here.
- 1
4.8 (182 reviews)· Memory Care, Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care· 91 units
Reviewers praise attentive, compassionate skilled nursing and rehab care, clean facilities, and staff who go above and beyond for residents and families.
- 2
4.8 (49 reviews)· Assisted Living
Most reviews are five-star, praising a warm, close-knit staff, activities like bingo and cards, and good food, though some raised care consistency concerns.
- 3
Renewity Residential Care Home
5 (13 reviews)· Assisted Living
This small assisted living home holds a perfect 5-star average, with families praising its low staff-to-resident ratio and personal attention.
- 4
4.9 (14 reviews)· Assisted Living, Independent Living, Memory Care
Families describe a warm, attentive community with personalized care across independent living, assisted living, and skilled nursing, plus frequent family-oriented activities.
- 5
Historic Silvercrest Patio Homes
4.5 (18 reviews)· Independent Living
Reviewers describe a well-run, beautiful campus with polite, caring staff and a strong activities program, though one visitor found it a bit stark.
- 6
4.4 (115 reviews)· Memory Care, Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care· 141 units
Families praise caring, attentive staff and strong rehabilitation outcomes, though the building is often described as older and needing cosmetic updates.
- 7
4.4 (43 reviews)· Assisted Living, Respite / Short-Term Care
Bennett Place is described as small and home-like with warm staff, a popular courtyard and dining room, though care consistency can vary.
- 8
4.5 (11 reviews)· Independent Living
Muir Manor offers affordable, income-based independent living for seniors 62 and older, with reviewers praising kind, responsive staff and a close community.
- 9
4.3 (166 reviews)· Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care· 156 units
Lincoln Hills is mainly used for short-term rehab, with families praising attentive nursing and therapy teams, good food, and caring social workers.
- 10
The Villages at Historic Silvercrest
4.2 (62 reviews)· Assisted Living, Independent Living, Respite / Short-Term Care, Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care· 56 units
Reviewers call it a warm, well-staffed community with strong nursing and rehab teams, easing transitions from independent living to higher levels of care.
What families say about senior living in New Albany
Counted across the review summaries of 29 New Albany communities: the share whose families mention each theme.
Families most often mention caring, attentive staff, cited in 83% of 29 communities, along with food and dining and medical or nursing care, each noted in 31%. On the complaint side, cost and billing come up in 52% of communities and communication with families in 41%, while staff attitude and staffing turnover are mentioned less often, at 17% and 10%.
Praised most
- Caring, attentive staff 83%
- Food and dining 31%
- Medical and nursing care 31%
- Activities and social life 28%
- Building and grounds 28%
Concerns raised
- Cost and billing 52%
- Communication with families 41%
- Staff attitude 17%
- Staffing levels and turnover 10%
“Been apart of the family here at Lincoln for several years. I love my residents and how great this place takes care of one another! EXCITED TO SEE OUR NEWLY RENOVATION COMING IN THE NEXT COUPLE OF MONTHS!!!!”
“My parents have lived at Mansion on Main since 2020 and the experience has been fantastic. The entire staff is welcoming from the office to the dining room and the nursing staff is exceptional. They always treated my parents with dignity and compassion.”
“My great Aunt has recently moved to Renewity. When they say Welcome Home they mean it! The staff has made her feel safe and comfortable. I know her needs are being taken care of and I am so happy we choose Renewity for her!”
Senior Living in New Albany: the figures
- •Of the 6 with a known size, 0 have ten residents or fewer, 1 have 11 to 60, and 5 have more than 60.
- •6 nursing homes carry a Medicare star rating, averaging 3.3 out of 5: 4 rated four stars or better, 1 rated one star.
- •Most common amenities: 24-hour staff (22), emergency call system (19), medication management (18), wheelchair accessible (14), housekeeping (14), social activities (13).
How families pay for senior living in Indiana
Most families in Indiana start by paying privately, drawing on savings, pensions, retirement accounts and often the proceeds from selling a home. Long-term care insurance, when a family has a policy in place, can also help cover the cost of assisted living, memory care or independent living, though the amount and terms vary by policy. Veterans and surviving spouses may qualify for VA Aid and Attendance, a benefit that helps offset care costs for those who meet the service and eligibility requirements.
The full picture for the state: Senior Living in Indiana.
Senior Living near New Albany
Cities within about 35 miles with senior living inventory, and how families rate it.
| City | Communities | RatingAverage rating | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clarksville3 mi | 5 | 3.4 / 5 | 3 mi |
| Jeffersonville5.3 mi | 9 | 4.1 / 5 | 5.3 mi |
| Louisville, Kentucky12.7 mi | 80 | 4.1 / 5 | 12.7 mi |
| Shelbyville, Kentucky33 mi | 9 | 4.4 / 5 | 33 mi |
All of Indiana: Senior Living in Indiana. Closer to home? Compare senior living near you, sorted by distance.
About these figures
Computed on October 21, 2026 from the 31 communities listed in New Albany, 1,054 public family reviews on Google, Yelp and MyLivingChoice, state licensing records and, for nursing homes, CMS Care Compare. The best-rated list ranks communities by average family rating weighted by how many families have reviewed each one, so a 4.9 from three reviews does not outrank a 4.7 from two hundred. No community pays to appear in the best-rated list or in these figures; sponsored and partner listings in the directory results are marked as such. Figures refresh as listings and reviews change; the written summary was last revised September 25, 2026.
Reading on this
Guides from MyLivingChoice that families in New Albany ask about.
- Home Care in Indiana: Agencies, Medicare Home Health Ratings, and What It Costs
- 7 Fun and Engaging Activities for Seniors in Indiana
- Top 5 Reasons You Should Live in Indianapolis
Not in New Albany? Senior living near me finds communities around wherever you are.
Senior Living in New Albany: Common Questions
How many senior living communities are in New Albany, Indiana?
MyLivingChoice lists 31 senior living communities in New Albany, Indiana, each with photos, care details, and reviews from families.
Which senior living communities in New Albany are rated highest?
Based on combined ratings across Google, Yelp, and MyLivingChoice reviews, top-rated options include Renewity Residential Care Home (5★, 13 ratings), SouthernCare (4.9★, 59 ratings), Help at Home (4.9★, 16 ratings).
What types of senior care are available in New Albany?
Beyond senior living, New Albany has at-home care (9 communities), assisted living (8 communities), independent living (7 communities), home health (6 communities), skilled nursing / long term care (6 communities). Every option is listed with photos, reviews, and contact details.
How do families rate senior living in New Albany?
Families rate New Albany senior living communities 4.2 out of 5 on average, across 1,054 public Google reviews of local communities.
What do families praise, and complain about, in New Albany senior living communities?
Across the review summaries of 29 New Albany communities, the most common praise is caring, attentive staff (mentioned for 83%), food and dining (mentioned for 31%), medical and nursing care (mentioned for 31%). The most common concerns are cost and billing (52%), communication with families (41%), staff attitude (17%).
Are there small senior living homes in New Albany?
Of the 6 New Albany communities with a known size, 0 have ten residents or fewer, 1 has 11 to 60, and 5 have more than 60. Small licensed homes are listed here alongside large communities, which most directories skip.
How do New Albany nursing homes score on Medicare's star ratings?
6 Medicare-certified nursing homes in New Albany carry an overall star rating, averaging 3.3 out of 5. 4 are rated four stars or better and 1 is rated one star. Each listing shows its rating and three years of inspection history from CMS Care Compare.
Prefer to stay home?
Home care agencies serving New Albany bring help to the house: daily living, companionship, and respite for family caregivers.
