3.9(31 ratings)· New Castle average: 4.4
Own this agency? Update your listing · Marketing for operators
An automated summary of family reviews and public information. Not verified by MyLivingChoice; confirm services, staffing and pricing with the community.
Families largely praise Bethany Cares for compassionate, attentive home health staff who go out of their way to help both patients and their relatives during difficult times. A few reviewers highlight the friendly, professional office team, though one report describes a frustrating breakdown in communication and follow-through.
AI-generated from reviews and community data.
Bethany Cares Home Health Agency is a home health agency serving New Castle, Indiana offering Home Health. Families rate it 3.9 out of 5 across 31 reviews.
Bethany Cares Home Health Agency is a home health care provider serving New Castle, Indiana. The agency offers personalized home health services including homemaking and attendant care, with a focus on treating clients with respect and honesty while addressing individual needs.
The agency's mission centers on providing compassionate, personalized care that supports quality of life for clients. Services are designed to align with each client's specific needs and preferences to ensure comfort and security in their home environment.
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit. Free for families.
Help Me Choose3.9overall · 31 ratings combined
3.9★ on Google (31)
Zach Schermerhorn
Feb 2026
This place is a JOKE they suck at communicating they don't call you back you tell them things they completely disregard They DO NOT KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING. Please just do your research before using this company we have had a terrible experience And I really don’t want anybody else having the same experience!!
Tracie Chaney
Sep 2023
Excellent care given to my family member. Staff is very friendly and caring about not only the patient but the families needs if they can help during difficult decision making times. Very grateful for them in my families time off need. Highly recommend this company to everyone.
Lynnee Melling
Sep 2023
Bethany is a great nurse and a great business owner. She is very caring about her patients and staff. She's great to work with.
Katherine Pence
Sep 2023
My experience was very positive. They really care about their clients and will go out of their way to help. At the office everyone is so nice, professional, and courteous. I had a good experience and will recommend their home health care to anyone on need.
Mason Warren
Sep 2023
This Place is one of the only Companies that allowed their employees to work without the Covid 19 Sham, or being forced to get the deadly vaccine which has caused many friends and family life long illnesses. Bethany Cares is 3 steps ahead when it comes to our ignorant politicians and uneducated leaders in power. The nursing homes were an absolute disaster through out the pandemic, Bethany Cares actually saved lives and kept families together through honoring religious exemptions. God Bless🙌🏻🙌🏻
Bethany Cares Home Health Agency offers Home Health.
Bethany Cares Home Health Agency is located at 3637 IN-3 Indiana 3 in New Castle, Indiana.
Bethany Cares Home Health Agency carries a 3.9 out of 5 rating from 31 Google reviews. Families largely praise Bethany Cares for compassionate, attentive home health staff who go out of their way to help both patients and their relatives during difficult times. A few reviewers highlight the friendly, professional office team, though one report describes a frustrating breakdown in communication and follow-through. Reviews on MyLivingChoice come from families who confirmed a connection to the community and appear with the reviewer's first name and last initial.
Submit the Request Information form on this page, or contact Bethany Cares Home Health Agency directly, to arrange a tour. Sharing your timeline and care needs up front helps the community prepare for your visit.
Work at Bethany Cares Home Health Agency? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details. It's free.
Other senior living options within 25 miles of New Castle.
New Castle, Indiana1.6 mi
4.7(34)
Independent Living
New Castle, Indiana1.7 mi
4.9(38)
Independent Living
New Castle, Indiana2.6 mi
4.9(63)
Assisted Living
New Castle, Indiana2.9 mi
4.6(60)
Assisted LivingMemory CareSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care
New Castle, Indiana2.9 mi
4.4(25)
Memory CareSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care
New Castle, Indiana2.9 mi
4.3(38)
Respite / Short-Term CareSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care