MyLivingChoice

Mother Angeline McCrory Manor

5199 E Broad St

3.8(78 ratings)

Mother Angeline McCrory Manor — photo 11 / 8

Quick Facts

Care model
Full continuum from independent living to skilled nursing on-site
Memory care unit
Secure dementia unit available on-site
Religious affiliation
Catholic, sponsored by Carmelite Sisters order
Specialist medical access
On-site ophthalmology and dermatology specialists

What Families Think

Mother Angeline McCrory Manor is a faith-based, non-profit Catholic community in Columbus offering the full continuum from independent living through skilled nursing, rehab, and hospice. Many families praise the warmth, spiritual care, and rehab outcomes their loved ones experienced, though a significant number of reviewers describe serious lapses in nursing attentiveness, staffing levels, and communication, especially for long-term and memory care residents.

The Good

  • Strong physical/occupational therapy outcomes praised repeatedly
  • Warm, faith-centered atmosphere with chaplain and daily Mass
  • Staff described as compassionate and treating residents with dignity
  • Facility frequently called clean and well-maintained
  • Continuum of care from independent living to skilled nursing on one campus

The Bad

  • Multiple reports of understaffing affecting attentiveness
  • Several serious complaints about missed vitals, medications, or catheter care
  • One-off but severe reports of neglect leading to hospitalization or death
  • Memory care residents described as lacking specialized dementia programming
  • Some reviewers cite poor communication and unresponsive administration

AI-generated from reviews and community data.

About Mother Angeline McCrory Manor

Overview

Caring for someone isn't just a job, it’s a compassionate calling that is based on deep-rooted spiritual beliefs. At Mother Angeline McCrory Manor, we are experts in creating individualized plans, treating each, unique person and their family with compassion and dignity.

We are called to a higher standard of values. Personal warmth, love and care will reflect and give value and purpose to our residents lives.

An array of medical services is available based on each resident’s needs. Each care plan includes input from the resident and family and is modified as needs are assessed. The dignity of each resident is our top priority.

Skilled Nursing

Mother Angeline McCrory Manor is a non-profit Healthcare Facility that offers experienced nursing and ongoing guidance to residents.

Mother Angeline McCrory Manor is a non-profit Health Care Facility sponsored by the Carmelite Sisters for the Aged and Infirm. Our nursing and medical care are guided by compassion and high standards of care. Caring for someone isn't just a job, it’s a compassionate calling that is based on deep-rooted spiritual beliefs.

Our experienced, supportive and concerned staff offers ongoing guidance to residents and family members. We are called to a higher standard of values.

The whole therapy department was great and really focused on my needs.

Short Term Rehabilitation Resident

•    Beautiful Courtyard with Fountain
•    Beauty/Barber Shop
•    Buckeye Lounge
•    Cable TV
•    Chaplain on Staff, Chapel w/ Daily Mass
•    City Center Cafe
•    Financial Planner
•    Gift Shop
•    Neighborhood Dining Rooms
•    Public Computer & WiFi Access

    Licensed Dietitian

•    Nursing Care
•    Palliative Care
•    Professional Social Worker
•    Secure Dementia Unit
•    Spiritual Team
•    Hospice
•    Pain Management
•    Ophthalmology & Dermatology
•    Medication Management

Rehabilitation

Short-Term Rehabilitation Care at Mother Angeline McCrory Manor specializes in treating diagnoses related to orthopedic, neurological and complex medical problems.

Rehabilitation Care Overview

The rehabilitation team at Mother Angeline McCrory Manor can create and carry out a treatment plan to get you back to your daily life.

We offer our outstanding Short Term Rehabilitation Program that specializes in treating diagnoses related to orthopedic, neurological and complex medical problems. Treatment progresses from assessment to discharge planning for the short term patient returning home.

The whole therapy department was great and really focused on my needs.

Short Term Rehabilitation Resident

Rehabilitation Services

•    Ambulation
•    Functional Mobility
•    Flexibility
•    Functional Strength
•    Balance
•    Coordination
•    Edema
•    Equipment Needs

    Activities of Daily Living

•    Dressing
•    Feeding
•    Hygiene
•    Assistive & Adaptive
•    Equipment
•    Community Re-entry
•    Fine Motor Skills

    Homemaking Activities

•    Swallowing Disorders
•    Communication Disorders
•    Diet Modification
•    Licensed Dietary Specialist
•    Discharge Care Manager
•    Skilled Nursing Care
•    Spiritual Team

Our philosophy of care centers on promoting healing care and Honoring thy Father and thy Mother.

Types of Care

Assisted LivingAt-Home CareHome Health and HospiceIndependent LivingSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care

Amenities

Room Amenities

  • Private Rooms
  • Wi-Fi / High-Speed Internet

Meals & Dining

  • Dietary Accommodations (Gluten-Free, Low / No Sodium, No Sugar, Vegan)

Community Amenities

  • 24-Hour Staff
  • Fitness Center
  • Gathering / Activity Spaces
  • Housekeeping
  • Laundry Service
  • Medication Management
  • On-Site Medical Staff
  • Outdoor Patio
  • Salon / Barber
  • Transportation Services
  • Walking Paths

Activities

  • Social Activities (Happy Hour, Wine Tasting, Dances, Karaoke)

Need help deciding?

Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit — free, and you choose who contacts you.

Help Me Choose

Reviews

3.8overall · 78 ratings combined

3.8★ on Google (70) · 3.4★ on Yelp (8) · Yelp page ↗

King P

Jun 2026

via Google

My grandma recently had surgery and is rehabilitating in this facility. While there, she's stated that the caretakers are neglectful, never take vitals, or given med when she's in pain. It honestly hurt me when I call to ask how she feeling. PLEASE HIRE PEOPLE WHO HAVE SOME UNDERSTANDING ON HOW TO BLS

a wolf

Mar 2026

via Google

Great community!! Offers every service from IL to skilled nursing. Caring staff! Definitely worth a look if you are looking for a new supportive home for your loved one.

Bethany W

Mar 2026

via Google

This is an amazing community. They are always attentive to all of the residents.

Brandon Boyd

Mar 2026

via Google

Mother Angeline McCrory Manor has been a staple healthcare community on the east side for decades.<br>They have provided fine care to several of my loved ones over the years and having a community that offers all levels of senior care in one place is great.

Briana Carter

Mar 2026

via Google

Ashley (Liaison) is so nice and great personality!

Request information

Ask about availability, pricing, or a tour. Your details go only to Mother Angeline McCrory Manor — never sold or shared.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of care does Mother Angeline McCrory Manor offer?

Mother Angeline McCrory Manor offers Assisted Living, At-Home Care, Independent Living and Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care.

Where is Mother Angeline McCrory Manor located?

Mother Angeline McCrory Manor is located at 5199 E Broad St in Columbus, Ohio.

What do families say about Mother Angeline McCrory Manor?

Mother Angeline McCrory Manor is a faith-based, non-profit Catholic community in Columbus offering the full continuum from independent living through skilled nursing, rehab, and hospice. Many families praise the warmth, spiritual care, and rehab outcomes their loved ones experienced, though a significant number of reviewers describe serious lapses in nursing attentiveness, staffing levels, and communication, especially for long-term and memory care residents.

Work at Mother Angeline McCrory Manor? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details — it's free.

Nearby Communities

Other senior living options within 25 miles of Columbus.