MyLivingChoice

The Addison of St. Johns

115 Benton Lane

4.7(52 ratings)· St. Augustine average: 4.4

Part of Sonida Senior Living · all operators · 112 communities · 4.5★ average

Own this community? Update your listing · Marketing for operators

The Addison of St. Johns, photo 11 / 2

Quick Facts

Starting price
$4,200/mo
Total units
85
Licensed capacity
85 residents

Florida AHCA

Memory care setting
Secured memory care neighborhood called Magnolia Trails
Short-term options
Respite care and short-term stays for recovery

What Families Think

An automated summary of family reviews and public information. Not verified by MyLivingChoice; confirm services, staffing and pricing with the community.

Families describe a community with warm, engaged staff and a secured memory care neighborhood, though one detailed account raises serious concerns about care oversight, cleanliness, and communication during a resident's hospitalization. Overall sentiment is largely positive, with reviewers praising activities and staff attentiveness, but the negative report highlights gaps that matter for anyone considering memory care here.

What reviewers praise

  • Staff described as warm, respectful, and engaged
  • Residents treated with dignity per reviewer
  • Bright, clean common areas noted by a reviewer
  • Creative, entertaining activities for residents
  • Secure memory care setting with homelike routines
  • Respite care and short-term stays offered

What reviewers flag

  • One detailed report of housekeeping lapses and a cockroach problem in memory care
  • One report of cameras installed in a resident's room without consent
  • One report of billing issues and delayed care plan communication
  • One report of no staff contact during a resident's 22-day hospitalization

AI-generated from reviews and community data.

The Addison of St. Johns is a senior living community in St. Augustine, Florida offering Assisted Living, Memory Care and Respite / Short-Term Care. Amenities include Gathering / Activity Spaces, Social Activities and Housekeeping. Published pricing starts around $4,200 per month. Families rate it 4.7 out of 5 across 52 reviews.

About The Addison of St. Johns

The Addison of St. Johns is a senior living community offering assisted living and memory care services in historic Saint Augustine, Florida. The community provides personalized care designed to support independence and well-being, with daily support for personal care, dining, and activities for residents who wish to maintain their independence.

The community features Magnolia Trails, a secure memory care setting with homelike routines that honor dignity and connection, as well as respite care and short-term stays for recovery or trial periods. Apartments include modern conveniences such as emergency response systems, walk-in showers with grab bars, and various layouts to suit different lifestyles.

Life at The Addison of St. Johns emphasizes connection and wellness through a range of programs and activities, including volunteer opportunities that support local and national causes. Residents have access to engaging activities and the ability to pursue hobbies within the welcoming community spaces.

The community is situated in the nation's oldest city, offering proximity to historic attractions and modern conveniences. Nearby restaurants include Columbia Restaurant, Cap's on the Water, and The Reef Restaurant, while shopping options encompass Cobblestone Village, St. Augustine Outlets, and Riverside Center. Local destinations such as Anastasia State Park, Castillo de San Marcos, and the St. Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum are accessible to residents.

The Addison of St. Johns is pet-friendly and provides a safe environment with open spaces and programs designed for residents and their animal companions.

Types of Care at The Addison of St. Johns

Assisted LivingMemory CareRespite / Short-Term Care

Amenities

Room Amenities

  • Emergency Call System
  • Private Bathroom
  • Private Rooms
  • Wheelchair Accessible

Meals & Dining

  • Dietary Accommodations (Gluten-Free, Low / No Sodium, No Sugar, Vegan)

Community Amenities

  • 24-Hour Staff
  • Gathering / Activity Spaces
  • Housekeeping
  • Laundry Service
  • Medication Management

Activities

  • Social Activities

Need help deciding?

Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit. Free for families.

Help Me Choose

Reviews of The Addison of St. Johns

4.7overall · 52 ratings combined

4.7★ on Google (52)

pat gilman

Apr 2026

via Google ↗ · Report

We visited on a Saturday. Played games. Staff was very helpful

Chrissy Daniel

Aug 2025

via Google ↗ · Report

Mom was in memory care for 5 months. The Memory care unit went months without housekeeper resulting in cockroach problem, very little activities for memory care residents, installed cameras in bedrooms without my consent for ‘ fall prevention’ yet no cameras in all common areas. Requested a care plan meeting and was told over 2weeks, various staff were ‘unavailable’ to participate. I was then emailed a care plan that i wasn’t included in the meeting,, and was billed retroactively to date of careplan, an additional 400/month fee. Lack of knowledgeable caregivers was an ongoing problem with constant change of staff. I felt compelled to check on my mom daily, and had friends visit a couple of hours a day to keep mom’s room/bedding/bathroom clean. My mom was sent to the hospital due to a behavioral change. She spent 22 days in the hospital with not one person from The Addison inquiring about her…i notified them at day 6 in hospital that i wasn’t sure she would be able to return. I asked if about a balance on her rentI heard back 2 weeks later with amount of monies due. Again, no inquiry of my mom’s health. I went in the evenings to remove her things as not to disturb the other residents and the night staff were genuinely concerned about my mom. Such little oversight from Ahca in terms of patient staff ratio with Alf’s and memory cares due to mostly private funds involved—no Medicare monies …and they all are bought and sold because they are big business/moneymakers.

Kandi S

Aug 2023

via Google ↗ · Report

The atmosphere of the Benton House is peaceful, family-loving and all inclusive of family members of residents and Day Care. My husband has attended day care for a year and the same staff is in place, and make us feel like family. Patients are well loved and cared for. It all begins with Matthew, the Administrator, Jessica, Receptionist, Amanda and Jackson who plan exeptional social activities that are creative and fun! Kym and staff in the Memory Care area, provide meaningful and fun art activities for the residents, as well as field trips to restaurants, movies and fun explorations in the area. No wonder they are rated #1in the nation by US World & News Report! They deserve it! If you are looking for a quality residential living or day care for a loved one, this is it!

Penny Levy

May 2021

via Google ↗ · Report

My mother moved into The Beacon, Benton House of St. Johns’ memory care community, in October of last year. Despite the stressful limitations of COVID-19 protocol, the staff at Benton House helped make the move go smoothly In stark contrast to Mom’s previous assisted living community, Mom is well cared for and treated with a high level of dignity. The rooms and common areas are bright, cheerful, and clean. The menu options are varied and look delicious. Activities are creative and entertaining. During my biweekly visits the other residents appear happy and content, greeting me enthusiastically. While other communities struggled to keep their residents engaged and content during the pandemic lockdown, the staff at Benton House excelled.

Diana Walker Music

Apr 2021

via Google ↗ · Report

It is our distinct pleasure to perform live music at Benton House-St. Johns! We are always met with respect, warmth, and professionalism by the staff. We are very impressed with the residents who love connecting with us. They enjoy the music and love singing along, clapping, and dancing! It is our pleasure and privilege to be a part of these amazing people’s lives! Highly recommend if you are searching for that special place for your mom or dad!

Request information

Ask about availability, pricing, or a tour.

Have you already been in touch with The Addison of St. Johns?

By submitting, you're okay with us and The Addison of St. Johns reaching out by phone, email or text.Always free for families. If you move in, the community you chose pays us a referral fee, never you; any nearby communities we suggest are chosen by your answers, never by what they pay us. Referral agreements are our only tie to the communities we list. If a community stops meeting our qualifications, for example its licence lapses or it stops accepting referrals, we stop suggesting it. How we work · FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of care does The Addison of St. Johns offer?

The Addison of St. Johns offers Assisted Living, Memory Care and Respite / Short-Term Care.

How much does The Addison of St. Johns cost?

Published pricing at The Addison of St. Johns starts around $4,200 per month. Final costs depend on care needs and apartment selection; contact the community for a detailed quote.

Does The Addison of St. Johns offer respite or short-term stays?

Yes. The Addison of St. Johns lists respite and short-term care among its options. A respite stay gives a family caregiver a planned break while your loved one receives full care, and it also works as a low-commitment trial before a permanent move.

Where is The Addison of St. Johns located?

The Addison of St. Johns is located at 115 Benton Lane in St. Augustine, Florida.

What do families say about The Addison of St. Johns?

The Addison of St. Johns carries a 4.7 out of 5 rating from 52 Google reviews. Families describe a community with warm, engaged staff and a secured memory care neighborhood, though one detailed account raises serious concerns about care oversight, cleanliness, and communication during a resident's hospitalization. Overall sentiment is largely positive, with reviewers praising activities and staff attentiveness, but the negative report highlights gaps that matter for anyone considering memory care here. Reviews on MyLivingChoice come from families who confirmed a connection to the community and appear with the reviewer's first name and last initial.

How can families visit The Addison of St. Johns?

Submit the Request Information form on this page, or contact The Addison of St. Johns directly, to arrange a tour. Sharing your timeline and care needs up front helps the community prepare for your visit.

Work at The Addison of St. Johns? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details. It's free.

Nearby Communities

Other senior living options within 25 miles of St. Augustine.

Prefer to stay home?

Home care agencies serving St. Augustine bring help to the house: daily living, companionship, and respite for family caregivers.

Reading on this