MyLivingChoice

Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community

11230 State Route 364

4.7(23 ratings)

Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community — photo 11 / 5

Quick Facts

Total units
53
Medicare rating
4 of 5

CMS Care Compare

Ownership
For profit, Corporation
Certified beds
53
Contract Type
Month-to-month rental, no buy-in fee required
Care Continuum
Independent living through skilled nursing on one campus
Affiliation
Faith-based, nonprofit organization
Couples Policy
Couples with different care needs can stay together

What Families Think

Families describe Otterbein St. Marys as a welcoming, well-kept lakeside community where staff and neighbors quickly make new residents feel at home. Reviewers highlight the smooth move-in process, responsive maintenance, and a full slate of activities, along with the financial reassurance of the community's rental structure.

The Good

  • Friendly, welcoming staff and residents
  • Quick, hassle-free move-in and maintenance response
  • Numerous activities and social events
  • Waterfront setting on Grand Lake
  • No upfront investment required for housing
  • High resident satisfaction across reviews

AI-generated from reviews and community data.

About Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community

Otterbein St. Marys is a continuing care retirement community located in St. Marys, Ohio, on the shore of Grand Lake, the state's largest inland lake in northwest Ohio. The community offers a full continuum of care including independent living, assisted living, long-term care, memory support, and post-acute and rehabilitation care, allowing residents to transition between levels of care on one connected campus.

Residents can choose from waterfront patio homes or apartments that suit their needs and preferences. Independent living residents benefit from priority access to future care if needed, and couples with different care needs can remain together on campus. The community offers flexible contract options with month-to-month rental fees and no required upfront investment or asset transfers.

Amenities at Otterbein St. Marys include a Life Enrichment Center with a warm-water pool, a fitness center, a community room with regular events, and weekly programs and outings. The lakeside setting provides opportunities for peaceful boat rides and sunset viewing. The Otterbein Ambassadors program, consisting of resident volunteers, helps new residents acclimate to campus life and make connections with fellow residents.

Located in Auglaize County approximately 29 miles from Lima, Ohio and 63 miles from Dayton, Ohio, the community is positioned for residents seeking an active lifestyle with access to both recreational activities on campus and proximity to regional amenities. The organization is guided by faith-based principles and operates as a registered 501(c)(3).

Types of Care

Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care

Need help deciding?

Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit — free, and you choose who contacts you.

Help Me Choose

Reviews

4.7overall · 23 ratings combined

4.7★ on Google (23)

Deborah Seelow

Dec 2025

via Google

Everyday I meet someone that is happy that I am here. The residents, the staff, everyone have been welcoming, helpful and ready to assist. I recommend this place as a place to live and enjoy their days.

Ronda Hershberger

Oct 2025

via Google

I recently spent an entire day at Otterbein St. Mary's and I was so impressed with the campus. For starters, it's a beautiful setting, the buildings and grounds were neat and tidy, it's tastefully decorated and I love the amenities they offer. The thing I enjoyed the most were the friendly people! What a great place!

Jenny Scheitz

Aug 2025

via Google

So happy to be at Otterbein! My move was very simple and Maintenance arrived and hooked up TV and Internet the same afternoon . Lots of activities for many levels of ability. Staff is friendly and helpful. Love my neighbors and the friendships I have made on our street. Thanks to all!!

Phyllis Fraga

Jul 2025

via Google

Otterbein St Marys is a very beautiful location near a lake. Friendly residents and staff. Many choices to choose from.

LeeAnn Collins

Jul 2025

via Google

The new homes on the lake are so beautiful. I love the option to have the boat dock.

Request information

Ask about availability, pricing, or a tour. Your details go only to Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community — never sold or shared.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of care does Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community offer?

Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community offers Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care.

Where is Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community located?

Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community is located at 11230 State Route 364 in St Marys, Ohio.

What do families say about Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community?

Families describe Otterbein St. Marys as a welcoming, well-kept lakeside community where staff and neighbors quickly make new residents feel at home. Reviewers highlight the smooth move-in process, responsive maintenance, and a full slate of activities, along with the financial reassurance of the community's rental structure.

Work at Otterbein St. Marys SeniorLife Community? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details — it's free.