MyLivingChoice

Autumn Bay

539 E Wisconsin Ave

2(12 ratings)· Pewaukee average: 4.1

Autumn Bay, photo 1

Quick Facts

Licensed capacity
22 residents

California CDSS

Entry Access
Locked doors requiring staff-entered keypad code

What Families Think

Autumn Bay is a small assisted living community in Pewaukee, Wisconsin, and it has received largely negative feedback from families online, with a Google rating around 2 out of 5 across the available reviews. Multiple reviewers describe serious concerns about staffing levels, resident safety, communication with families, and restrictive visitation policies, alongside a couple of reviews calling the facility and staff positive.

The Good

  • A couple of reviewers call staff wonderful
  • One reviewer says it's a good assisted living option

The Bad

  • Multiple reports of unsafe or rough resident handling by staff
  • One report of an unattended, unmonitored entrance risking wandering
  • One report of missing belongings with no follow-up from staff
  • One report of restrictive visitation limited to one hour weekly
  • One report of medication and medical equipment mismanagement
  • One report of poor communication with family (POA) during a medical crisis

AI-generated from reviews and community data.

Autumn Bay is a senior living community in Pewaukee, Wisconsin offering Assisted Living. Families rate it 2.0 out of 5 across 12 reviews.

About Autumn Bay

Autumn Bay is a assisted living community in Pewaukee, Wisconsin.

Families rate Autumn Bay 2.2 out of 5 based on 13 Google reviews.

Contact the community directly to ask about availability, pricing, and tours, or browse the photos and reviews here to see if it could be the right fit for your family.

Types of Care at Autumn Bay

Assisted Living

Need help deciding?

Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit. Free, and you choose who contacts you.

Help Me Choose

Reviews of Autumn Bay

2overall · 12 ratings combined

2★ on Google (12)

Shannon LW

Jul 2026

via Google

My mother was in the advanced stages of Alzheimers when she was admitted to Autumn Bay. Hospice was engaged to assist with her care. Her condition rapidly deteriorated at the facility. My father witnessed two care givers boost my mom up on the bed so hard her head banged into the headboard. My mother cried out in pain. A few days later, hospice care advised the family my mother was in the active stage of dying. When we arrived at the facility, no one was with my mother, she lay unresponsive and laboring to breathe. About an hour later, a member of our family had to leave, and friends came to the facility to sit with us and mom but couldn't get in. No one can enter or exit without staff entering a code at the door. We searched for a staff member by walking throughout the facility, looking in the office and kitchen, but we found no one. A sign on the front entrance says that if you push on the door for 15 seconds, an alarm will sound and it will open. We did that because a family member had to get out and friends had to get in. The alarm continued to sound, so I continued searching for staff but still couldn't find anyone. I called the Director but there was no answer and a message that she was out until Thursday of that week. I found a bulletin board with emergency contacts. I started calling the numbers until someone answered, because the door was still open and the alarm going off. A resident in a wheel chair passed me in the hall calling for help. I relayed everything to the person who answered one of the emergency numbers. I returned to my mother's room, eventually a staff member came in, she was on the phone with the Director who wanted to speak with me. She chastised me for calling the emergency numbers. I asked, "What would you have me do? Family had to leave, friends had to get in, my mother is dying, a man is calling for help in the hall and the alarm was going off." She said they are not a concierge service. I think that meant that anyone who has to leave that building has to wait until staff appears. I don't think that is safe. It is also not safe that any resident could do the same thing I did to open the door, it is not monitored and that alarm went off until I called the emergency numbers, got someone who then called the staff members. In summary, concerns with the facility are (1) my mom's head was banged on the headboard by staff boosting her up. (2) The entrance is unattended, residents at risk of wandering can get out. (3) There isn't enough staff. (4) Little to no support as my mom lay dying. (5) Emergency numbers are posted but we were chastised for utilizing them. Sadly, my mother passed away early the next morning. The experience was made worse by her residence at Autumn Bay.

Leah Cannizzaro

Jan 2024

via Google

Things missing from my aunt’s room and no one seems to care.

MARE

Jan 2022

via Google

Warning ⚠️ The staff cut off all communication with residents, went in residents room and purposely turned off the residents cell phone closed the blind and doors are always locked there.. You need to be let in and out with someone pushing a code on key pad? Just like in prison. They say no visitors allowed on weekends have to have a 48hour approved 1 hour only per week visit, but only allow 1 family per week , there are 20 residents there?? How is this appropriate to keep loved ones from their families. Staff will not answer questions to what meds were given ,they went without shower or being washed up for 5 days, even though they threw up on themselves. Family POA'S were not called when resident was sick and throwing up. There was a welfare check done on the resident that resulted in a Ambulance to the hospital because of the poor condition the resident was in and hospitalized for a week.The reason our loved one was there was for memory care .The owners daughter believes in no verbal communication, she is rude and believes she will make all of the residents medical decisions and try to cut out the familys facilitating the medical care they need, let's staff lie to residents, speaks to them in a demeaning manner. The resident went without a emergency medical pendant for 5 days there, we were given multiple excuses why the resident went without it, none of which were valid. This was absolutely unacceptable the residents safety was in jeopardy. The residents calls for help went unanswered by staff. Staffs only response to any questions asked ie.. why no shower was given we were told "we don't do that on the weekends". They are running a skeleton crew , who is not trained appropriately to care for the needs of elderly or memory care people. Another thing is they open all the residents mail, and claim they do that because they don't want a resident to get a bill in the mail ?? They are essentially doing their best to keep families from their loved ones.You get a run around with the staff only person who you may or may not be able to talk with in an email only is the owners daughter... sad a loved one is kept isolated by them and not cared for well in their golden years. I wished I would have listened to one of the residents the day before moving our loved one there, a sweet lady in the hallway cried out says "please help me its like a prison here they don't let family come and visit." Don't put your loved one here and wherever they go please check up on them and often. I'm sorry our loved one went through what they did for 5 days they were there. From the first day resident was brought there the Administrator was not there to make a smooth transition. The staff knew nothing about the bag of meds from the rehab or what to even do with them,nor how to use the cpap machine and or give nebulizer treatments correctly??

Jennifer Lemke

Aug 2018

via Google

I went to go visit my Grams today, I am beyond words how poorly she was treated and the way the staff talked about her while using profanity. How sad to the individuals that live there, I prayed the Lord watches over them all and the staff can find it in their hearts to be kind to all our loved ones that reside there.

Request information

Ask about availability, pricing, or a tour. Your details go only to Autumn Bay, never sold or shared.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of care does Autumn Bay offer?

Autumn Bay offers Assisted Living.

Where is Autumn Bay located?

Autumn Bay is located at 539 E Wisconsin Ave in Pewaukee, Wisconsin.

What do families say about Autumn Bay?

Autumn Bay is a small assisted living community in Pewaukee, Wisconsin, and it has received largely negative feedback from families online, with a Google rating around 2 out of 5 across the available reviews. Multiple reviewers describe serious concerns about staffing levels, resident safety, communication with families, and restrictive visitation policies, alongside a couple of reviews calling the facility and staff positive.

How can families visit Autumn Bay?

Submit the Request Information form on this page to connect with Autumn Bay and arrange a tour. Sharing your timeline and care needs up front helps the community prepare for your visit.

Work at Autumn Bay? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details. It's free.

Nearby Communities

Other senior living options within 25 miles of Pewaukee.