Best Senior Living in New Hartford, New York
7 communities found
MyLivingChoice lists 7 senior living communities in New Hartford. Families rate them 4.1 out of 5 on average, across 160 public reviews.
- 7communities
- 4.1average rating, 6 rated
- 160family reviews read
The Community at Sunset Wood
New Hartford, New York
4.8(20)
Independent Living
Cedarbrook
New Hartford, New York
5(4)
Assisted Living
Raymond L. Garrett
New Hartford, New York
Assisted LivingSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Presbyterian Residential Community
New Hartford, New York
4(24)
Independent Living
Preswick Glen
New Hartford, New York
3.7(6)
Independent Living
Sitrin Health Care Center
New Hartford, New York
3.8(75)
Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Presbyterian Homes & Services
New Hartford, New York
3.1(31)
Assisted LivingSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care
Best-rated senior living in New Hartford
Ranked by family rating, weighted by how many families have reviewed each one. No community pays to appear here.
- 1
4.8 (20 reviews)· Independent Living
The Community at Sunset Wood is an independent living community in New Hartford, NY, for residents 62 and older, run by a non-profit organization dating back to 1882. While the community holds a strong 4.8 Google rating…
- 2
Presbyterian Residential Community
4 (24 reviews)· Independent Living
Presbyterian Residential Community in New Hartford, New York holds a 4 out of 5 rating from 24 Google reviews, with most reviewers praising the compassion of the nursing and care staff. A smaller number of reviews raise…
- 3
3.7 (6 reviews)· Independent Living
Preswick Glen is an independent living community in New Hartford, New York, with a Google rating of 3.7 out of 5 based on 6 reviews. No detailed reviews, amenities, or pricing information were provided, so specific…
- 4
3.8 (75 reviews)· Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care· 188 units
- 5
3.1 (31 reviews)· Assisted Living, Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care· 242 units
What families say about senior living in New Hartford
Counted across the review summaries of 7 New Hartford communities: the share whose families mention each theme.
Praised most
- Activities and social life 43%
- Building and grounds 43%
- Food and dining 29%
- Medical and nursing care 29%
- Caring, attentive staff 14%
Concerns raised
- Communication with families 57%
- Cost and billing 57%
- Building and upkeep 29%
- Staff attitude 14%
“Wonderful facility, caring staff, great activities, delicious meals. I feel my mother is safe & content with independence living here.”
Senior Living in New Hartford: the figures
- •Most common amenities: housekeeping (6), gathering / activity spaces (6), laundry service (5), 24-hour staff (5), social activities (5), wheelchair accessible (5).
Senior Living near New Hartford
Cities within about 35 miles with senior living inventory, and how families rate it.
All of New York: Senior Living in New York. Closer to home? Compare senior living near you, sorted by distance.
About these figures
Computed on October 23, 2026 from the 7 communities listed in New Hartford, 160 public family reviews on Google, Yelp and MyLivingChoice, state licensing records and, for nursing homes, CMS Care Compare. The best-rated list ranks communities by average family rating weighted by how many families have reviewed each one, so a 4.9 from three reviews does not outrank a 4.7 from two hundred. No community pays to appear in the best-rated list or in these figures; sponsored and partner listings in the directory results are marked as such. Figures refresh as listings and reviews change.
Reading on this
Guides from MyLivingChoice that families in New Hartford ask about.
- Home Care in New York: Agencies, Medicare Home Health Ratings, and What It Costs
- Nursing Home vs. Assisted Living: Which Level of Care Does Your Loved One Actually Need?
- Signs It Is Time to Move From Home Care to Assisted Living
Not in New Hartford? Senior living near me finds communities around wherever you are.
Senior Living in New Hartford: Common Questions
How many senior living communities are in New Hartford, New York?
MyLivingChoice lists 7 senior living communities in New Hartford, New York, each with photos, care details, and reviews from families.
Which senior living communities in New Hartford are rated highest?
Based on combined ratings across Google, Yelp, and MyLivingChoice reviews, top-rated options include The Community at Sunset Wood (4.8★, 20 ratings), Presbyterian Residential Community (4★, 24 ratings), Sitrin Health Care Center (3.8★, 75 ratings).
What types of senior care are available in New Hartford?
Beyond senior living, New Hartford has assisted living (3 communities), independent living (3 communities), skilled nursing / long term care (3 communities). Every option is listed with photos, reviews, and contact details.
How do families rate senior living in New Hartford?
Families rate New Hartford senior living communities 4.1 out of 5 on average, across 160 public Google reviews of local communities.
What do families praise, and complain about, in New Hartford senior living communities?
Across the review summaries of 7 New Hartford communities, the most common praise is activities and social life (mentioned for 43%), building and grounds (mentioned for 43%), food and dining (mentioned for 29%). The most common concerns are communication with families (57%), cost and billing (57%), building and upkeep (29%).