MyLivingChoice

Saint Johns on the Lake

1858 N PROSPECT AVE

4.4(42 ratings)· MILWAUKEE average: 3.8

Request Information
Saint Johns on the Lake — photo 11 / 6

Quick Facts

Medicare rating
4 of 5

CMS Care Compare

Ownership
Non profit, Church related
Certified beds
27
Contract type
Life Care contract, entrance-fee continuing care model
Specialized peer support
On-site support network for residents with Parkinson's

What Families Think

Reviewers describe Saint John's on the Lake as a lively, service-oriented independent living community with strong dining, active programming, and a caring front-line staff, especially for residents in independent living and those in the on-site Parkinson's support group. However, one detailed report raises serious concerns about safety practices and staff conduct within the skilled nursing/long-term care side of the community.

The Good

  • Warm, attentive staff frequently praised by families
  • Extensive daily activities, classes, and cultural programming
  • Highly rated on-site dining at Taylor's and Prospect Grill
  • Supportive peer community for residents with Parkinson's
  • Residents describe feeling safe, secure, and at home

The Bad

  • One detailed report of serious safety lapses in skilled nursing care
  • One account of delayed fall-prevention equipment and slow incident follow-up
  • One report of inappropriate staff conduct toward a family member
  • No published pricing information available

AI-generated from reviews and community data.

Saint Johns on the Lake is a senior living community in MILWAUKEE, Wisconsin offering Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care. Amenities include Guest Meals, Restaurant style Dining Room and Outdoor Patio. Families rate it 4.4 out of 5 across 42 reviews.

About Saint Johns on the Lake

Saint John's on the Lake is a senior living community set in three towers on the bluffs of Lake Michigan in Milwaukee. The community offers studio, one, two, and three-bedroom apartment homes with lake and city views, each described as maintenance-free and featuring a variety of amenities.

As a Continuing Care community, Saint John's is designed to meet residents' lifelong health care needs while allowing them to enjoy their desired lifestyle. The community offers a Life Care contract intended to provide security in planning for future health care while protecting residents' financial resources, with contract options designed to suit different budgets and estate planning needs.

The community's person-centered philosophy and LifeStreams Wellness Program address seven dimensions of wellness: emotional, environmental, intellectual, occupational, physical, social, and spiritual. Residents have daily opportunities for spiritual, cultural, and educational growth.

Amenities include a fitness center and landscaped gardens overlooking Lake Michigan, along with extensive community spaces intended to foster connections and social opportunities. Programming includes fitness classes, wine tastings, and access to local cultural offerings.

Located within Milwaukee, residents can take advantage of the surrounding city's cultural tapestry in addition to on-site activities and amenities.

Types of Care at Saint Johns on the Lake

Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care

Amenities

Room Amenities

  • Cable or Satellite TV
  • Emergency Call System
  • Multiple Floor Plans
  • Private Bathroom
  • Private Rooms
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Wi-Fi / High-Speed Internet

Meals & Dining

  • Dietary Accommodations (Gluten-Free, Low / No Sodium, No Sugar, Vegan)
  • Guest Meals
  • Restaurant style Dining Room

Community Amenities

  • 24-Hour Staff
  • Chapel / Religious Services
  • Fitness Center
  • Gathering / Activity Spaces
  • Housekeeping
  • Laundry Service
  • Medication Management
  • On-Site Nurse (RN)
  • Outdoor Patio
  • Salon / Barber
  • Security
  • Transportation Services
  • Walking Paths

Activities

  • Arts and Crafts
  • Birthday / Holiday Parties
  • Day Trips and Outings
  • Games
  • Live Performances
  • Religious Services
  • Social Activities (Happy Hour, Wine Tasting, Dances, Karaoke)

Need help deciding?

Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit — free, and you choose who contacts you.

Help Me Choose

Reviews of Saint Johns on the Lake

4.4overall · 42 ratings combined

4.4★ on Google (42)

Debra Jones

Mar 2026

via Google ↗

Horrible experience! If I could rate zero I would! Supposed to be known for exceptional staff. What a joke. Staff do not exhibit safety and consistency with safety equipment, asked and signed for rails on bed and fall mat on Tues, grab bars did not get put on bed until Friday, pt fell Tuesday night when trying to get up during a fire drill at night!! We got the floor mat on Thursday when the admin went to get it. First to call was never called, never notified of knee abrasions, they did get him a hip X-ray but never notified of results. Thurs almost fell because no one was holding onto his gait belt which family had to insist staff use when getting pt up. Pt stated he was left in bathroom by himself for long period on toilet after recent fall. Nursing assistant spoke inappropriately to family which confrontation ensued, with family as witness administration states family cannot return to see father. Administration would not speak on nursing assistant status but if the staff is allowed to speak to family members inappropriately how are the residents being treated when they are at their own defenses! Totally inappropriate.

Peter Pruessing

Mar 2026

via Google ↗

My wife and daughter and I had dinner at Taylor’s Restaurant in St. John’s and we all found it to be excellent. Our food was very good (exceeded our expectations) and the service was excellent as well - friendly, efficient, and professional. The menu had a surprisingly broad selection and we found the preparation to be very appetizing. We plan to go again. I would highly recommend Taylor’s to anyone!

James Hartwig

Nov 2025

via Google ↗

Taylor's dining team provided us a wonderful evening. We were celebrating a special birthday with friends. As Shore Holder Club members, St. John's entire staff has been helpful and welcoming to make us feel at home. Sincerely, Jim and Rhonda Hartwig..

Su Rablin

Aug 2025

via Google ↗

St. John's is the best! As a family member of a 9 year independent living Mom, it gives me great joy every time I come to St John's on the Lake! Not only is her apartment decorated and perfectly suited for her, she can feel safe & secure living there. Staff is wonderful, kind and accommodating. Both Taylors and the Prospect Grill offer delicious choices, unique recipes, and wonderful service. There are such an abundance of opportunities for things to do and take part in... nobody sits around like a bump on a log. But, if you want your alone time to regenerate, read a book or just take a nap, it's all up to you. Find your peace, joy and fulfillment at St John's on the Lake. Just see Luci! Tell her Su sent you!

Krystal Kimmel

Jul 2025

via Google ↗

Our father moved into St. Johns in early 2023 at our urging. Although he was unsure at the time, It has been the perfect place for him. The programming and learning opportunities available are endless - he is trying new things all the time! He has found an amazing group of friends and support within the Parkinson's community. The care and attention from the staff is amazing; from the receptionists to the nursing staff, to the administration. They have all made it feel like home for both our dad and the family. We couldn't be happier that he has the opportunity to age gracefully in such a thriving environment!

Request information

Ask about availability, pricing, or a tour. Your details go only to Saint Johns on the Lake — never sold or shared.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of care does Saint Johns on the Lake offer?

Saint Johns on the Lake offers Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care.

Where is Saint Johns on the Lake located?

Saint Johns on the Lake is located at 1858 N PROSPECT AVE in MILWAUKEE, Wisconsin.

What do families say about Saint Johns on the Lake?

Reviewers describe Saint John's on the Lake as a lively, service-oriented independent living community with strong dining, active programming, and a caring front-line staff, especially for residents in independent living and those in the on-site Parkinson's support group. However, one detailed report raises serious concerns about safety practices and staff conduct within the skilled nursing/long-term care side of the community.

How can families visit Saint Johns on the Lake?

Submit the Request Information form on this page to connect with Saint Johns on the Lake and arrange a tour. Sharing your timeline and care needs up front helps the community prepare for your visit.

Work at Saint Johns on the Lake? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details. It's free.

Nearby Communities

Other senior living options within 25 miles of MILWAUKEE.

Edenbrook Lakeside

Edenbrook Lakeside

MILWAUKEE, Wisconsin0 mi

3.4(63)

Skilled Nursing / Long Term Care

Chai Point Senior Living

Chai Point Senior Living

Milwaukee, Wisconsin0.2 mi

5(9)

Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care+2 more

Hedwig House

Hedwig House

Milwaukee, Wisconsin0.2 mi

5(1)

Independent Living

Ovation Communities

Ovation Communities

Milwaukee, Wisconsin0.2 mi

3.6(45)

Assisted LivingMemory CareSkilled Nursing / Long Term Care

St. Rita Square

St. Rita Square

Milwaukee, Wisconsin0.3 mi

4.7(38)

Assisted LivingIndependent Living

Eastcastle Place

Eastcastle Place

Milwaukee, Wisconsin1.2 mi

4.7(86)

Assisted LivingIndependent LivingMemory Care+1 more