MyLivingChoice

Maplewood at Mayflower Place

579 Buck Island Road

4.5(31 ratings)

Maplewood at Mayflower Place — photo 11 / 5

Quick Facts

Total units
38
Medicare rating
3 of 5

CMS Care Compare

Ownership
For profit, Limited Liability company
Certified beds
72
Community type
Only CCRC on Cape Cod
Rehab center
72-bed JCAHO-accredited rehabilitation center
Care continuum
Independent living through memory care on one campus

What Families Think

Reviewers largely praise Maplewood at Mayflower Place for attentive, compassionate staff and a smooth transition into assisted living, along with strong rehab and dining experiences. One detailed review, however, raises concerns about management turnover, declining food quality, and unmet promises around staffing, suggesting some inconsistency over time.

The Good

  • Staff described as caring and compassionate
  • Smooth, low-pressure transition into assisted living
  • Positive rehab experience with attentive therapists
  • Dining staff praised for attentiveness and personal touch
  • Clean, inviting, and vibrant atmosphere

The Bad

  • One report of frequent turnover in senior management
  • One report that food quality has declined over time
  • One report that promised 24-hour nursing coverage isn't provided
  • One report of unclear or missing fire drill procedures for residents

AI-generated from reviews and community data.

About Maplewood at Mayflower Place

Maplewood at Mayflower Place is a continuing care retirement community in West Yarmouth, Massachusetts, offering independent living, assisted living, memory care, and rehabilitation services. As the only CCRC on Cape Cod, it provides full-service senior living options designed to evolve with residents' changing needs.

The community features memory care programs and a 72-bed, JCAHO-accredited rehabilitation center with state-of-the-art services and a highly trained team of experts. Licensed care is available on-site for residents who need personalized support, with compassionate caregivers focused on helping residents maintain dignity and independence.

Residents enjoy spacious apartments with thoughtful finishes and conveniences, along with fine dining experiences and an abundance of programs designed to engage diverse interests. The community emphasizes freedom from household upkeep while providing personalized daily living support.

Located in West Yarmouth, the community is situated amid the natural attractions of Cape Cod, including endless beaches, golf courses, miles of hiking and walking trails, cranberry bogs, and local dining and entertainment options. The setting provides opportunities for outdoor recreation and community engagement.

Types of Care

Assisted Living

Need help deciding?

Tell us what you're looking for and we'll match you with communities that fit — free, and you choose who contacts you.

Help Me Choose

Reviews

4.5overall · 31 ratings combined

4.5★ on Google (31)

Robert Biddleman

Feb 2026

via Google

My mother in-law has lived here for about three years. This location has a constant change of senior management. It seems to be very poorly run. The food has gone downhill significantly. It seems they never have fire drills, which seems completely unsafe. Evidently the employees have fire drills, but it's unclear to the residents what they're supposed to do. there are some great employees in the apartments are OK but at 7000+ per month it seems you should be getting better service. they claimed to have 24 hour nursing coverage, which they do not. Lots of promises made during the marketing tour that just don't pan out when you live there.

scott lonkart

Jan 2026

via Google

As anyone can imagine the transition from personal residence to independent-assisted living can happen overnight and certainly be an adjustment. Maplewood at Mayflower Place made that transition very seamless. Being our first experience Pam Fletcher and the staff guided us from "A to Z" with absolute perfection and never pressured us once. Everyone is so helpful and inviting. The residents are beyond friendly and take a very active role in their community, very welcoming atmosphere with endless activities. The grounds and facility are beautiful from the library when you enter, atrium, the bistro & dinning hall, plus a world class swimming pool & gym. Not to mention the little things which count most including the warm colors throughout, numerous gathering areas, and a very attentive/responsive maintenance staff. We sleep better now knowing my Mom is in such a beautiful and safe community that also allows for her complete independence, we enjoy visiting tremendously.

Kristie Anderson

Jan 2026

via Google

My dad spent a week at Maplewood at Mayflower Place for rehab after a fall and we had a very positive experience! The staff was kind, attentive, and professional. The food was great! We have no complaints and appreciate the care he received while there.

Jane Allard

Jan 2026

via Google

I can't say enough great things about the therapists at Mayflower Place. From day one, their patience, kindness, and genuine compassion made me feel supported and cared for. Their upbeat attitudes and encouragement truly lifted me on difficult days, and their knowledge and dedication gave me confidence in my recovery. They don't just treat patients-they care deeply about people. I am incredibly grateful for everything they've done for me. I was able to return home and live my life again. Highly recommend.

Catharine

Nov 2025

via Google

My mother started her stay at Maplewood at Mayflower as a patient in the nursing portion receiving top care. She transferred to their assisted living home on site as a trial for one month. She loves it so much, she is making it her forever home! We as family members could not be happier. The staff are professional, caring and compassionate. We are impressed by Courtney, the male server in the dining room, who greets all guests with a huge smile, kind welcoming voice and maintains eye contact with whoever is speaking. He is serving each table while multi tasking with the (many!) requests each guest has. His memory and care of each person makes everyone feel valued and heard. His customer service is incredible. We also enjoy Cat, the activities director who makes rounds to each table and ensures all guests know about the days activities from what movie is being shown in the film room, the live music at the piano and the many other options that keep our seniors minds working and socializing happening. Meredith, an executive director, is also thoughtful and helpful. We are impressed by the care and concern all staff give our mom and family. The facility itself is clean, inviting and happy. The dining room provides delicious and nutritious meals and are thoughtful about providing unique requests. Our family has much less stress now knowing our mom/sister/aunt/grandma/cousin is being cared for in a vibrant, caring and compassionate place. Thank you Maplewood at Mayflower!

Request information

Ask about availability, pricing, or a tour. Your details go only to Maplewood at Mayflower Place — never sold or shared.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of care does Maplewood at Mayflower Place offer?

Maplewood at Mayflower Place offers Assisted Living.

Where is Maplewood at Mayflower Place located?

Maplewood at Mayflower Place is located at 579 Buck Island Road in Yarmouth, Massachusetts.

What do families say about Maplewood at Mayflower Place?

Reviewers largely praise Maplewood at Mayflower Place for attentive, compassionate staff and a smooth transition into assisted living, along with strong rehab and dining experiences. One detailed review, however, raises concerns about management turnover, declining food quality, and unmet promises around staffing, suggesting some inconsistency over time.

Work at Maplewood at Mayflower Place? Claim this listing to update photos, pricing, and details — it's free.