8275 Craig St

Indianapolis Indiana 46250

0.0 rating based on 1,234 ratings

0 User Reviews

Phone Number

Contact Name



  • On-Site Medical Staff
  • Chef Prepared Meals
  • Dietary Accommodations
  • Transportation Services
  • Housekeeping
  • Laundry Service
  • 24-Hour Staff
  • Medication Management
  • Security
  • Planned Activities
  • Pet Friendly
  • Multiple Floor Plans
  • Private Rooms
  • Fitness Center
  • Activity Space
  • Theater Room
  • Beauty Salon
  • Outdoor Patio
  • Walking Paths
  • Free Wi-Fi

Living Types

  • Senior Living
  • Assisted Living
  • Independent Living
  • Memory Care
  • Nursing Home
  • At-Home Care
  • Respite Care


Sycamore Reserve is the second independent senior living community we’ve developed. The first, Bartlett Reserve, located in Durham, North Carolina has enjoyed great success and was awarded Senior Advisor’s Best of Senior Living, by its residents and their family members, multiple years in a row.

You’ll appreciate the convenience of being in Castleton on the northside of Indianapolis close to I-69, I-465, Community Hospital North, IU Health Hospital Saxony, St. Vincent’s Hospital North, a variety of grocery stores, restaurants, specialty shops and shopping at the largest mall in Indiana: Castleton Square Mall. We are very excited to be an integral part of The City of Indianapolis’ new Castleton Revitalization Plan.

“I am heartend to hear of the plans. The new senior living community will be exciting news for area residents.”
Christine Scales, Indianapolis City County Council
We think there is a better way for seniors to enjoy their independent lifestyle. We’re obsessively passionate about it, and it’s our mission to help you live life to the fullest. Our dedicated team is always here to help.
Theresa has more than 15 years of experience in the senior living industry as an Executive Director, licensed Administrator and Director of Sales and Business Development. She has a broad knowledge and understanding of the senior housing market, with a proven track record of successful business and census development.

Theresa has 4 beautiful children, loves being outdoors, enjoys fishing, boating and pretty much anything to do with the water. She has an unending love for God, family values and a commitment to serving seniors within her communities.
Josie joined AGS Capital as Vice President of Accounting and Chief Financial officer for AGS’s portfolio of companies, including Sycamore Reserve in April 2015. Prior to that, she worked at Kemper CPA Group for over seven years.

In her private life, she’s been a member of Columbia Club of Indianapolis for over 22 years, served on the board of directors for 12 years and just completed two years as president of the board. The Columbia Club has 90 plus overnight guest rooms, dining venues, a fitness center and all the service challenges a guest/membership organization handles.

From 2010-2015 she was a volunteer and served on the board of directors of Hancock County Senior Services, Inc., a non-profit agency that focuses on meeting the needs of the senior population through transportation, home support and other services. She has volunteered and delivered Meals on Wheels for over 7 years, interacting with many senior citizens in various economic and social situations.

Josie is a cum laude graduate of Indiana University, with a BS in Accounting. She is a Certified Public Accountant and a member of the AICPA and the Indiana Society of CPAs.

Josie has been married to Carroll for 40+ years and they have a grown daughter, Autumn. They love to travel, experience fine cuisine and volunteer to help those less fortunate.
Shawn’s 16 years of senior living experience has given her a deep passion for serving the senior population. She has worked for several senior living companies, most recently with Riverwalk Commons in Noblesville. Born and raised in Indianapolis, the youngest of eight children, Shawn has a strong desire to be part of a large family. This trait is displayed as she treats all her residents and their loved ones as part of her ever-growing family.

Shawn currently resides in Carmel with her daughter, Kelsey, who graduated from nursing school in December 2019 and her two Dachshunds, Frank and Odie and mini Goldendoodle, Moose. Shawn is also a Proud Army Mom, with her son, Kyle, serving in the US Army in Fort Campbell, Kentucky. Her daughter, Ali, works as an IT Medical Recruiter for Medasource in Chicago. In her spare time, Shawn enjoys Pilates, traveling, doing anything outdoors and spending as much time as possible with her two beautiful granddaughters, Lyla and Eve.
Chef Jose brings over 22 years of culinary experience to Sycamore Reserve. He began his career as a Sous Chef at Ruth’s Chris Steak house, has a degree in Culinary Arts from The Chef’s Academy of Indianapolis and has continued to hone his culinary skills in the kitchen as a banquet chef at Kahn’s Catering. He has a true passion for the foods people know and love and enjoys helping them try new things.

Jose is Serve Safe certified and has experience organizing and catering events for up to 5,000 guests.
For the past four years, Michelle Herren has served as Director of Activities for senior living communities here in Indianapolis. Prior to that, she operated a very successful childcare/preschool in the Annapolis, Maryland area. She also served as a teacher’s aide for children with special needs. Her entire adult career she has cared for others.

Now as our Life Enrichment Director at Sycamore Reserve, she is very excited about the endless opportunities for personal and team growth. She feels we truly focus on educating and training our staff, giving our residents and their loved ones the most active and independent experience possible.

In her spare time, Michelle enjoys her family including her seven children and pets. She is an excellent artist and seamstress, which explains why the residents she serves have such a great time in her planned classes and events.

“I am eager to implement my caring, compassionate, and competent nature and join the other Sycamore team members who make the residents their absolute priority. We are invested in the happiness and quality of life of our residents, and I cannot wait to continue my part in making that happen here at Sycamore Reserve.”
Cindy Dudley
Cindy Dudley
Certified Organic Gardener & Life Enrichment Assistant
Cindy is one of the most dynamic individuals at Sycamore Reserve. She graduated from Franklin Central High School, was office manager for her husband Dr. Tim Dudley and managed the Waterman Family Farms for 7 years.

She’s volunteered for Big brother Big Sisters of America, Global Peace, has been on 4 mission trips to Kenya and 16 mission trips to Jamaica. Her passion for helping others makes it no surprise that she’s received the Paul Harris Volunteer award from Rotary International.

Cindy has been married to Tim Dudley for over 25 years. She enjoys gardening, reading, biking and spending time with family and friends.

Property Gallery


Connect With Us


Explore many other top senior living communities in your city.